LRO-28-008-9009 / 9010; Rights of NM Copper, Gray and Frost

Final Subfile Order and Judgment- Filed 12-12-2023

Notice of Withdrawal of Appearance- Filed 1-30-2024

Entry of Appearance and Substitute Counsel and Notice of Change of Address- Filed 11-15-2023

Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law on Remand- Copper Flat Inter Se- Filed 8-23-2023gray

Notice of Unavailablity – Filed 11-30-2022gray

Notice of Unavailibilty 2- Filed 1-18-2023gray

Notice of Unavailibilty- Filed 1-18-2023gray

Receipt for Exhibits- Filed 5-19-2022gray

Notice of Hearing- NM Copper Frost Gray- Filed 5-5-2022gray

Release of Exhibits- Filed 4-29-2022gray

NM Copper Corp Brief in Response to SNM Brief on Remand-Filed 4-4-2022gray

NM Copper Corp Brief in Response to Brief of the HIllsboro Mutual – Filed 4-4-2022gray

Turner Ranch Properties LPs Reponse to NMCC’s Brief in Chief on Remand- Filed 4-4-2022gray

NM Copper Corp Consolidated Brief in Response to Turner Ranch Properties Brief- Filed 4-4-2022gray

Notice of Unavailability- Filed 3-30-2022gray

State of New Mexico’s Response Brief on Remand to NM Copper Corp Brief on Remand- Filed 4-4-2022gray

Notice of Non-availability- Filed 3-9-2022gray

Brief Turner Ranch- Filed 2-28-2022gray

Brief Hillsboro Mutual- Filed 2-28-2022gray

Brief NM Copper Corp- Filed 2-28-2022gray

Turner Ranch Request to Propose Supplemental Finding of Fact and Conclusions of Law-Filed 2-28-2022gray

State of New Mexico’s Brief on Remand with Proposed Supplemental Findigs of Fact and Conclusions of Law- Filed 2-28-2022gray

Exhibit Receipt- FIled 2-2-2022gray

Scheduling Order-LRO-280089009 NM Copper-Filed 1-12-2022gray

Notice of Hearing – Filed 12-22-2021gray

Request for Setting-Filed 12-16-2021gray

Order on the Mandate- Filed 12-17-2021gray

Memorandum- Filed 12-7-2021gray

Order Regarding an Extension of Time; 11-21-16gray

Order Denying Request to File Rebuttal Brief; 11-21-16gray

Certificate of Stenographic Record by Vickie L. Isaacs; 11-15-16gray

Certificate of Stenographic Record by Sally A. Rubino; 11-15-16gray

Certificate of Stenographic Record by Elsie R. Porter; 11-15-16gray

Receipt for Exhibits; 11-07-16gray

Hillsboro Claimants’ and Turner Ranch Properties, L.P’s Joint Reply to Claimants’ Response to Joint Motion for Extension to file Proposed FFC & Trial Briefs; filed 11-7-16gray

NM Copper Company et al Response to Joint Motion for Extension of Time to File FFCL and Trial Briefs; filed 11-4-16gray

Joint Motion for Extension of Time to File Proposed Findings of Fact and Trial Briefs; 10-25-16gray

Certificate of Service for Hillsboro and TRP Joint Motion for Extension of Time to File Proposed Findings and Post-Trial Briefs; 10-25-16gray

Notice of Telephonic Status Conference; 10-27-16gray

William Frost’s, Harris Gray’s and New Mexico Copper Corporation’s Consolidated Reply Brief in Support of Motion to Dismiss; 12-23-15gray

Turner Ranch Properties, L.P.’s Trial Exhibit List; 2-10-16gray

NM Copper Corporation’s, William Frost’s, and Harris Gray’s Requested Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law; 3-4-16gray

William Frost, Harris Gray, and New Mexico Copper Corporation’s Final Exhibits; 2-10-16gray

Turner Ranch Response in Opposition to NM Copper, Gray and Frost’s Motion to Dismiss Defendants from this Expedited Inter Se Proceeding for Lack of Standing or, Alternatively, Request for Stay of Proceedings; 12-1-15gray

William Frost, Harris Gray, and New Mexico Copper Corporation’s Final Witness List; 2-10-16gray

State of New Mexico’s Witness and Exhibit List; 2-10-16gray

Turner Ranch Properties, L.P.’s Reply to Claimants’ Response to Objections to Testimony of William Frost; 3-2-16gray

William Frost, Harris Gray, and New Mexico Copper Corporation’s Designation of Deposition Testimony; 2-10-16gray

Certificate of Service – Hillsboro Claimants; 2-10-16gray

Hillsboro Claimants’ Deposition Designations; 2-10-16gray

Affidavit – Tanya Scott; 1-5-16gray

Affidavit – George Lotspeich; 1-5-16gray

Joint Motion for Designation of Stream System Issue and Expedited Inter Se of Water Rights Claimed by New Mexico Copper Corporation, et al., Under Subfile Numbers LRO-28-008-9010 and LRO-28-008-9009; 1-14-14gray

Order Denying Motion to Participate in Oral Argument; 1-7-16gray

Turner Ranch Properties, L.P.’s & Hillsboro Parties’ Joint Motion to Strike Affidavits; 1-6-16gray

Exhibits 3 of 3; 97 pgsgray

Entry of Appearance (R. Bruce Frederick); 1-14-14gray

City of Las Cruces’ Motion to Participate in Oral Argument in Support of Turner Ranch Properties, L.P’s Motion for Partial Summary Judgment and in Opposition to Harris Gray and William Frost’s, and the New Mexico Copper Corporation’s Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Standing; 1-5-16gray

Hillsboro’s Claimants Notice of Errata; 12-7-15gray

Notice of Completion of Briefing; 12-23-15gray

State’s Disclosure of Offers of Judgment; 12-2-14gray

Certificate of Service; 12-18-15gray

Notice of Dispositive Motion Hearing; 12-18-15gray

Turner Ranch Properties, L.P’s Reply to NM Copper Corporation’s, Harris Gray’s and William Frost’s Response to its Motion for Partial Summary Judgment as to Claims of Gray and Frost Under Subfile No. LRO-28-008-9010; 12-8-15gray

Exhibits 1 of 3; 74 pagesgray

Request for Rule 1-016 Scheduling Conference; 12-22-14gray

Certificate of Service; 12-15-15gray

Reply to NMCC’s Opposition to Partial Summary Judgment; 12-8-15gray

SNM’s Reply to Response of Frost, Gray and NM Copper Corporation to the Motion for Partial Summary Judgment of Turner Ranch Properties; 12-7-15gray

Notice of Scheduling Conference (set for 1-13-15 at 130 p.m.); 12-18-14gray

NMPG’s Notice of Intent to Participate in Expedited Inter Se of Claims of NM Copper Corp., Harris Gray and William J. Frost; 12-15-14gray

Turner Ranch Properties, L.P.’s Notice of Intent to Participate in Expedited Inter Se of Claims of New Mexico Copper Corporation, Harris Gray and William J. Frost; 12-8-14gray

SNM’s Response in Opposition to the Motion of the Copper Flat Claimants to Dismiss Participating Parties from this Expedited Inter Se Proceeding for Lack of Standing; 12-4-15gray

Notice of Intent to Participate in Expedited Inter Se of Claims of NM Copper Corp, Harris Gray and William J. Frost; 12-8-14gray

Statement of Claims Under Subfile Numbers LRO-28-008-9009 and LRO-28-008-9010 (by NM Copper, Harris Gray and William J. Frost); 11-24-14gray

Response in Opposition to Motion to Dismiss; 12-1-15 (Charles P. Barrett, Melody K. Sears, R. Wm. and Nolan Winkler, Robin Tuttle, Robert Shipley, Jim Goton, John and Agnes McGarvie, John and Cindy Cornell, Stanley and Joyce Brodsky, Arlene Lynch and the Hillsboro Mutual Domestic Water Consumers Association (“Hillsboro Claimants” or “Hillsboro”) Responding to the New Mexico Copper Company, William J. Frost and Harris Gray’s (“NMCC’s”) Motion to Dismiss)gray

New Mexico Copper Corporation’s, Harris Gray’s and William Frost’s Response to Turner Ranch Properties, L.P.’s Motion for Partial Summary Judgment as to Claims of Gray and Frost Under Subfile No. LRO-28-008-9010; 11-19-15gray

Exhibits 2 of 3; 105 pgsgray

Certificate of Service – (First Supplemental Set of Documents responsive to the 2nd Set of Request for Production of Documents of the NM Copper Corp); 11-30-15gray

SNM’s Withdrawal of Partial Summary Judgment Motion; 11-24-15gray

Turner Ranch Properties, L.P.’s Certificate of Service of Expert Rebuttal Report (James R. Kuipers, P.E); 10-2-15gray

NM Copper Corporation’s, Harris Gray’s and William Frost’s Response to the Joinder by Hillsboro Defendants in Turner Ranch Properties, LP’s Motion for Partial Summary Judgment as to Claims of Gray and Frost Under Subfile No. LRO-28-008-9010; 11-23-15gray

New Mexico Copper Corporation’s, Harris Gray’s and William Frost’s Motion to Dismiss Defendants from this Expedited Inter Se Proceeding for Lack of Standing; 11-16-15gray

Turner Ranch Properties, L.P.’s Motion for Partial Summary Judgment and Memorandum in Support as to Claims of Gray and Frost Under Subfile No. LRO-28-008-9010; 11-4-15gray

SNM’ Motion for Partial Summary Judgment, Joinder in Support of Partial Summary Judgment Motion of Turner Ranch Properties, and Memorandum in Support; 11-16-15gray

NM Copper Company’s, William Frost’s and Harris Gray’s Response to Turner Ranch Properties, LLC’s Motion for Protective Order; 10-19-15gray

PRETRIAL ORDER; 6-27-16gray

Objection to Offer of Judgment (Gray – 9010); 9-15-14gray

Hillsboro Claimants’ Joinder in the Turner Ranch Properties, L.P.’s Motion for Partial Summary Judgment and Memorandum in Support as to Claims of Gray and Frost Under Subfile No. LRO-28-008-9010; 11-9-15gray

Certificate of Service – Hillsboro Answers and Responses to NM Copper et al, 2nd set of Interrogatories and Requests for Production; 10-29-15gray

Certificate of Completion of Deposition re: Thomas C. Turney; 11-2-15gray

Certificate of Completion of Deposition re: Harris Gray; 11-2-15gray

Certificate of Completion of Deposition re: Jeff Smith; 11-2-15gray

Certificate of Service – NM Copper et al Supplemental Discovery Responses served; 10-30-15gray

Certificate of Service – Turner Ranch Properties, Answers to NM Copper et al’s 2nd Set of Interrogatories and Responses to 2nd Set of Request for Prod; 10-30-15gray

Certificate of Service – NM Copper etal – Responds to 1st Set of Interrogatories and Requests for Production; 10-30-15gray

Certificate of Service – Hillsboro 1st Supp Answers to NM Copper et al 1st Set of Interrogatories; 10-28-15gray

Turner Ranch Properties, L.P.’s Reply to Claimants’ Response to Motion for Protective Order; 10-19-15gray

Turner Ranch Properties Response to Claimants Objections to Testimony of G Emlen Hall; 3-3-16gray

Certificate of Service – Turner Ranch 1st Supplemental Answers to NM Copper et al’s First Set of Interrogatories; 10-26-15gray

Certificate of Service – Turner Ranch Properties 1st Supplemental Responses to NM Copper et al’s First Set of Requests for Production; 10-26-15gray

Amended Notice Duces Tecum to Take Deposition (Max Yeh); 10-21-15gray

Turner Ranch Properties, L.P.’s Motion for Protective Order; 10-14-15gray

Turner Ranch Properties, L.P.’s Supplemental Witness List; 9-17-15gray

Notice of Telephonic Hearing; 10-16-15gray

NMPG’s Notice of Withdrawal of Intent to Participate; 10-16-15gray

Notice Duces Tecum to Take Deposition – Max Yeh; 10-9-15gray

Notice Duces Tecum to Take Deposition – James R. Kuipers, PE; 10-9-15gray

Notice of Deposition Duces Tecum to John W. Shomaker, Ph.D; 9-28-15gray

Certificate of Service of Exhibits to Response to NMCCs Objections to Testimony of Dr Max Yeh; (1 of 2); 3-4-16gray

Amended Notice to Take Depositon of Robert Pratt; 10-9-15gray

Certificate of Service (NM Copper, Frost and Gray – serves 2nd Set of Interrogatories and 2nd set of Requests for Production to Turner Ranch and NMPG); 10-2-15gray

Certificate of Service (Barrett et al., 2nd Set of interrogatories and requests for production); 10-1-15gray

Notice to Take Deposition (Robert Pratt); 9-24-15gray

Amended Expert and Lay Witness Identification in Subfile Numbers LRO-28-008-9009 and LRO-28-008-9010; 9-18-15gray

Order Designating Expedited Inter Se Proceeding; 9-26-14gray

Notice of Non-Availability – Tessa T. Davidson; 9-23-16gray

Objection to Offer of Judgment (NM Copper – 9009); 9-15-14gray

Notice of Deposition Duces Tecum to Jeff Smith; 8-28-15gray

Notice of Deposition Duces Tecum to Harris Gray; 8-28-15gray

Notice of Deposition Duces Tecum to Thomas C. Turney, P.E; 8-28-15gray

Amended Notice of Deposition Duces Tecum to Thomas C. Turney, PC; 8-28-15gray

Certificate of Service; 8-10-15gray

Objection to Offer of Judgment (Frost – 9010); 9-15-14gray

Certificate of Service (re: Objection to Offer of Judgment 9009/9010); 9-15-14gray

Pre-Trial Exhibit List (by Hillsboro Claimants); 6-30-16gray

Certificate of Service of Expert Report; 8-10-15gray

Revised Scheduling Order; 8-4-15gray

Summons (LRO-28-008-9010); 7-31-14gray

Summons (LRO-28-008-9009); 7-31-14gray

Certificate of Service (Charles P. Barrett, et a., Answers to 1st Set of Discovery); 5-1-15gray

Affidavit of 7-29-2014 Mailing (LRO-28-008-9010); 7-31-14gray

Notice of Issuance of Summons (LRO-28-008-9010); 7-31-14gray

Affidavit of 7-29-2014 Mailing (LRO-28-008-9009); 7-31-14gray

Notice of Issuance of Summons (LRO-28-008-9009); 7-31-14gray

Certificate of Service for Joint Motion for Revised Schedule and (Proposed) Order; 7-16-15gray

Joint Motion for Modification in Case Schedule and Proposed Revised Scheduling Order; 7-16-15gray

Notice of Motion Hearing (set for 9-17-14 at 1:30); 7-24-14gray

Exhibits to Response to NMCCs Objections to Testimony of Dr Max Yeh; (2 of 2); 3-4-16gray

NM Copper Corp’s, Harris Gray’s and William Frost’s Notice of Unavailability; 6-29-15gray

Hillsboro Certificate of Service Pre-Trial Exhibit List; 6-30-16gray

Certificate of Service of Expert Report; 6-29-15gray

Notice of Vacating Telephonic Conference; 6-20-16gray

Notice of Telephonic Conference; 6-20-16gray

State of New Mexico’s Objections to Witnesses and Exhibits; 2-19-16gray

Joint Motion for Telephonic Conference; 6-16-16gray

Turner Ranch Properties, L.P.’s Certificate of Service of Expert Report; 6-26-15gray

Certificate of Service (SNM’s 1st Set of Discovery to Harris Gray, et al); 6-26-15gray

Certificate of Service (NM Copper, et al., answers Tuner Ranch discovery); 6-19-15gray

Certificate of Service (1st Set of Discovery by Charles P. Barrett et. al.); 5-21-15gray

Notice of Continuation of Trial; 5-16-16gray

Notice of Hearing – Testimony of Dr. Max Yeh; 5-16-16gray

Subpoena for Appearance of Person for Trial – George Lotspeich; 3-11-16gray

Notice of Non-Availability (Jonathan Block); 5-20-15gray

Certificate of Service (Turner Ranch Answers to 1st Set of Discovery); 4-21-15gray

Certificate of Service (NMPG Answers to 1st Set of Discovery); 4-21-15gray

Turner Ranch Properties, L.P’s Witness List; 4-17-15gray

First Witness List (Charles P. Barrett, et al.); 4-17-15gray

Expert and Lay Witness Identification in Subfile Numbers LRO-28-008-9009 and LRO-28-008-9010; 4-17-15gray

Certificate of Service (Turner Ranch Properties 1st Set of Discovery to William J. Frost, et al); 3-30-15gray

Notice of Non-Availability (Tessa T. Davidson); 3-25-15gray

Reply to the SNM’s Response to the Joint Motion for Designation of Stream System Issue and Expedited Inter Se of Water Rights Claimed by New Mexico Copper Corporation, et al., Under Subfile Numbers LRO-28-008-9010 and LRO-28-008-9009; 4-14-14gray

Certificate of Service (NMCC’s 1st Set of Discovery to Turner Ranch and NMPG); 3-24-15gray

Notice to Take Deposition Duces Tecum (Depo of James Hangen); 3-23-15gray

Notice to Take Deposition Duces Tecum (Depo of Cheryl Thacker); 3-23-15gray

New Mexico Copper Corporation’s, Harris Gray’s and William Frost’s Notice of Unavailability; 3-18-14gray

Briefing Schedule Regarding Joint Motion for Designation of Stream System Issue and Expedited Inter Se of Water Rights Claimed by New Mexico Copper Corporation, et al., Under Subfile Numbers LRO-28-008-9010 and LRO-28-008-9009; 3-13-14gray

Certificate of Service (Subpoena for Appearance of Persons for George Lotspeich); 3-11-16gray

Amended Notice of Deposition Duces Tecum to William Frost; 3-7-16gray

Notice of Deposition Duces Tecum to William Frost; 3-7-16gray

Unopposed Motion to Withdraw as Counsel – Bruce Frederick; 2-2-15gray

Turner Ranch Properties, L.P.’s Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law; 3-4-16gray

SNM’s Initial Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law; 3-4-16gray

Response to NMCCs Objections to the Testimony of Dr Max Yeh; (filed by Hillsboro Claimants); 3-3-16gray

Hillsboro Claimants’ Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law; 3-4-16gray

Order Denying Hillsboro Claimants’ and Turner Ranch Properties, L.P.’s Objections to New Mexico Copper Corporation, Harris Gray, and William Frost’s Designation of William Frost as a Fact Witness; and Order for the Deposition of William Frost; 3-4-16gray

Turner Ranch Properties, L.P.’s Response to Claimants’ Objections to Testimony of Jim Kuipers, P.E; 3-2-16gray

Entry of Appearance – Carey Bhalla obo Turner Ranch; 3-4-16gray

2nd Amended Notice of Pre-trial Conference; 3-4-16gray

Objections to Testimony of G. Emlen Hall; (filed by NM Copper, Frost and Gray); 2-19-16gray

Objections to Testimony of Max Yeh; (filed by NM Copper, Frost and Gray); 2-19-16gray

Response to Objections to the Testimony of William Frost; 2-29-16gray

Amended Notice of Pre-Trial Conference; 3-2-16gray

State of New Mexico’s Response to Motion to Set Stream System Issue on Right of New Mexico Copper, et al., and Reply to Response of New Mexico Copper, et al.; 2-19-14gray

Turner Ranch Properties, L.P’s Objections to Exhibits, Witnesses and Depostion Designations; 2-19-16gray

Joint Movants’ Reply to New Mexico Copper’s Response to Joint Motion for Designation of Stream System Issue and Expedited Inter Se of Water rights Claimed by New Mexico Copper Corporation, et al., Under Subfile Numbers LRO-28-008-9010 and LRO-28-008-9009; 2-28-14gray

Hillsboro’s Objections to Witnesses, Depositions and Trial Exhibits; 2-19-16gray

New Mexico Copper Corporation, Harris Gray and William Frost’s Objections to Testimony of Jim Kuipers, P.E; 2-19-16gray

Certificate of Service – Hillsboro Objections; 2-19-16gray

NM Copper Corporation, William Frost and Harris Gray’s Objections to Authenticity of Exhibits; 2-19-16gray

NM Copper Corporation, William Frost and Harris Gray’s Objections to Deposition Designations; 2-19-16gray

Notice of Trial; 2-17-16gray

Notice of Telephonic Pre-Trial Conference; 2-17-16gray

Turner Ranch Properties, L.P.’s Trial Witness List; 2-10-16gray

Turner Ranch Properties, L.P.’s Deposition Designations; 2-10-16gray

Scheduling Order; 1-23-15gray

Hillsboro Exhibit List; 2-10-16gray

Hillsboro Disclosure of Witnesses; 2-10-16gray

Order Denying Motion for Partial Summary Judgment; 1-15-16gray

Order Granting Unopposed Motion to Withdraw as Counsel; R. Bruce Frederick Withdraws; 2-3-15gray

New Mexico Copper Corporation’s Certificate of Service of Initial Disclosures; 2-3-15gray

Request for Setting; 2-3-14gray

Response to Joint Motion for Designation of Stream System Issue and Expedited Inter Se of Water Rights Claimed by New Mexico Copper Corporation, et al., Under Subfile Numbers LRO-28-008-9010 and LRO-28-008-9009; 2-3-14gray

Memorandum Order Denying Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Standing; 1-15-16gray

Certificate of Service-Davidson Initial Disclosure; 2-2-15gray

Limited Entry of Appearance; Douglas Meiklejohn, Eric D. Jantz and Jonathan M. Block; 2-2-15gray

LRO-28-008-9009 / 9010; Rights of NM Copper, Gray and Frost

Designation of Stream System Issue and Expedited Inter Se of Water Rights Claimed by the New Mexico Copper Corporation, Harris Gray and William J. Frost